Shelby County, IN Real Estate Search

Shelby County, IN Homes for Sale

The Real Estate Market in Shelby County, IN

Shelby County, Indiana, is a booming area for real estate with a variety of housing options available. From historic homes in charming downtown areas to modern developments in suburban neighborhoods, there is something for everyone in this diverse market. The median home price in Shelby County is currently around $170,000, making it an affordable option for first-time homebuyers and growing families.

Popular Neighborhoods in Shelby County

Some of the most sought-after neighborhoods in Shelby County include the city of Shelbyville, known for its quaint downtown and historic homes, and the town of Fairland, with its rural atmosphere and spacious properties. Other popular areas include Waldron and Morristown, both offering a mix of rural and suburban living options. Whether you're looking for a quiet country retreat or a bustling urban lifestyle, Shelby County has a neighborhood to suit your needs.

Market Trends in Shelby County

The real estate market in Shelby County has been steadily growing over the past few years, with an increase in both home sales and property values. The average days on the market for homes in Shelby County is currently around 60 days, indicating a high demand for housing in the area. With a strong economy and low unemployment rate, Shelby County is a desirable location for both homebuyers and investors looking to capitalize on the growing market.

Up-and-Coming Developments in Shelby County

Several new residential and commercial developments are in the works in Shelby County, including the expansion of retail and dining options in downtown areas and the construction of new housing developments in growing suburbs. With an emphasis on sustainable and eco-friendly design, these developments are attracting buyers looking for modern amenities and energy-efficient homes. As these projects continue to progress, Shelby County is expected to see a further increase in property values and market growth.

Investment Opportunities in Shelby County

For investors looking to capitalize on the growing real estate market in Shelby County, there are numerous opportunities available. From fixer-upper properties in up-and-coming neighborhoods to commercial developments in high-traffic areas, there are plenty of options for those looking to generate passive income or build their real estate portfolio. With a strong rental market and a steady influx of new residents, Shelby County is a prime location for real estate investment opportunities.

Our website features the best Shelby County, IN real estate search for homes available. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Shelby County, IN Homes for Sale

Avg. No of Beds
Avg. No of Baths
Avg. Living Ft2
Avg. Listing Price
Cost per ft2
Days on Market

Curious about what’s happening in the Shelby County, IN real estate market? Sign up for a  Shelby County, IN Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Shelby County, IN Homes for Sale

4 Beds 2 Baths
Welcome to this beautifully updated 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom bi-level home, offering a perfect blend of comfort, style, and functionality. Situated in a desirable neighborhood, this property features an attached 1-car garage and a fully fenced backyard, providing both privacy and security. Step inside to discover a brand-new kitchen, boasting sleek stainless steel appliances, new cabinets, and a spacious peninsula perfect for casual dining or entertaining. The kitchen seamlessly flows into the dining area, creating an open and inviting space for family meals and gatherings. The main level living room is bathed in natural light, thanks to its large windows, creating a warm and welcoming atmosphere. From here, step out onto the deck overlooking the backyard-a perfect spot for morning coffee or evening relaxation. Downstairs, you'll find an expansive family room, ideal for movie nights or a game room. An additional bonus room provides versatility for a home office, gym, or hobby space. The lower level also includes a large bedroom with a generous walk-in closet, offering a private retreat for guests or family members. This home is designed for both indoor and outdoor living, with plenty of space to accommodate all your needs. Don't miss the opportunity to make this stunning, move-in-ready property your forever home! Some of the updates include: all new flooring, a new a/c unit, water heater, sliding glass door, windows, appliances, kitchen cabinets and countertops, bathroom vanities, toiles, mirrors and fans, lighting, interior doors, electrical outlets, fresh paint, and baseboards.

921 N Hampton Boulevard, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Runnebohm Realty, LLC.

4 Beds 3 Baths
Discover country living at its finest with this charming 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom house nestled on a picturesque plot of land. Boasting a spacious 2-car attached garage, this home offers both convenience and functionality. Step inside to find a newly updated kitchen, complete with sleek granite countertops, perfect for culinary enthusiasts and entertainers alike. The open layout seamlessly flows into the dining area, making family meals and gatherings a joy. Relax and unwind in the comfort of the cozy living room, ideal for quiet evenings or hosting guests. With four bedrooms, there's ample space for a growing family or accommodating visitors. But the allure doesn't end there. Venture outside to discover a newly constructed deck, offering the perfect spot for enjoying morning coffee or evening sunsets. For those with furry or feathered friends, the fenced-in area provides a safe haven for animals to roam and play. And for those with hobbies or in need of extra storage, the barn offers endless possibilities. A bonus room that's more than just extra space; it's a sanctuary tailored to your desires. The attic offers a hidden treasure trove of storage possibilities, allowing you to declutter your living spaces and keep your belongings organized with ease. Whatever your passion, this bonus room promises to be the perfect backdrop for creating lasting memories. Make it your own and elevate your lifestyle with this unparalleled addition to your new home. Experience the serenity of country living while still being just a short drive from city amenities. Start envisioning a life filled with the sweet rewards of your very own fruit trees, the property offers peach and honeycrisp apple trees. Don't miss your chance to make this dream property your own. Schedule a showing today!

4030 S 250 E, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Mackenzie Allen, Polston & Ass.

4 Beds 4 Baths
Want to be a Homesteader? Fabulous custom built Hearthstone log home on 12.03 acres with all the amentities you desire! Inground heated 8.5 ft deep pool, covered outdoor built-in kitchen, trails through the woods to Coffey Creek. 4 bedrooms & 4.5 baths plus a finished walk-out basement housing the entertainment & family rooms, (pool table incld), wet bar & laundry plus, elec. baseboard for back-up heat. Beautiful 116 ft stone wall with wood burning fireplace in living rm. 200 yr old yellow pine (not yellow in color) floors from Norfolk VA. Custom built doors & closets. 3-zone HVAC, Heat pump with LP back-up. Tennessee Flag Stone walkway leads to a large covered porch with swing. Master bath has large slate shower plus separate jet tub, 2 sink vanity, also a walk-in closet. 15 x 20 Master bedroom has sitting area, vaulted beamed ceiling & hardware for barn door. Flatrock Furniture master bed, bar stools and table stay as well as pool furniture. Seller is willing to leave "cabin" style furnishing. Sit in the screened-in deck off of kitchen to watch wildlife in their natural habitat or, walk to the stone firepit to roast marshmallows, get back in to nature! There is a detached 2/3 car garage with floored storage above. Plenty of cleared space for a garden or orchard. The property is located just a few miles from town, Shelbyville, within 10 min to interstate, grocery stores, restaurants and all city amenities. There's only been 3 families to own this home, you can be the 4th! Please try to give 24 hr notice to show. Do not drive down lane without an appointment.

2483 N 200 E, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Carpenter, REALTORS®.

3 Beds 2 Baths
Welcome to your serene oasis. This charming 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom ranch-style home boasts a picturesque view overlooking a tranquil pond and beautiful sunsets, offering a retreat from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. As you step onto the property, you'll be greeted by a spacious front porch, perfect for enjoying your morning coffee or unwinding with a good book while soaking in the peaceful surroundings. The low-maintenance homes ensures that you have plenty of time for all your hobbies or hanging with friends and family. Step inside, and you'll be captivated by the open concept design, creating a seamless flow between the living, dining/kitchen areas. The kitchen features modern amenities including a pantry and island, ideal for both casual meals and entertaining guests. The home's thoughtful layout includes split bedrooms, providing privacy and comfort for all occupants. The master suite is a true haven, complete with a luxurious walk-in closet and en-suite bathroom, offering a peaceful retreat at the end of a long day. Venture outside to discover the enchanting back patio adorned with a pergola, offering the perfect spot for al fresco dining or simply basking in the beauty of nature. The partially fenced backyard provides a sense of seclusion while still allowing for ample space for your pet to enjoy outdoors. With the convenience of total electric utilities, this home offers both modern comfort and efficiency. Whether you're seeking a peaceful retreat or a welcoming space to entertain, this property offers the perfect blend of comfort, convenience, and natural beauty. Welcome home!

2209 Cherrybark Court, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Runnebohm Realty, LLC.

Makeup: A 2 BR, 1BR, and Studio at $750, $745, and $500. Invest in a Lucrative Triplex Generating over almost $2000 Monthly Income In today's dynamic real estate market, finding an investment opportunity that promises both stability and significant returns is paramount. Introducing a prime investment opportunity: a meticulously maintained triplex boasting three units and generating almost $2,000 (rents are on the lower side) in monthly rental income. This triplex is not just a property; it's a pathway to financial prosperity and security. Unlocking the Potential: With three distinct units, each contributing to the impressive monthly income, this triplex offers investors a rare opportunity to diversify their income streams and maximize returns. Whether you choose to rent out all three units or occupy one while leasing the others, the potential for profit is undeniable. Location, Location, Location: Situated in a highly sought-after area, this triplex benefits from its prime location, surrounded by amenities, downtown restaurants and shopping, trail heads, and convenient transportation options. The demand for rental properties in such desirable neighborhoods ensures a steady stream of potential tenants, minimizing vacancies and maximizing rental income potential. Crunching the Numbers: Let's talk figures. With around $2000 in monthly rental income and room to improve those numbers, this triplex yields an annual income that surpasses $15,000 before debt service. Such impressive numbers speak volumes about the financial viability of this investment opportunity. Moreover, with the potential for rental rate increases and property appreciation over time, the long-term returns on investment are even more promising. Rates could be nearer $900, 750, and 700.

225 W Pennsylvania Street, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Mackenzie Allen, Polston & Ass.

5 Beds 6 Baths
Welcome to Shetland Acres Estate - a 21-acre property with a stunning custom-built home is a testament to luxury and sophistication. Just 25 a minute drive outside of Indianapolis. As you arrive through the private entrance, a world of exclusivity unfolds before you. The main residence, meticulously designed and crafted, boasts a perfect blend of elegance and timeless charm. Step inside to discover a floor plan bathed in natural light, accentuating the limestone floors and custom finishes throughout. The spacious living areas seamlessly flow into a gourmet French-country style kitchen, equipped with top-of-the-line appliances and exquisite countertops - a haven for culinary enthusiasts. The allure of this property extends beyond the walls of the main house. Imagine evenings filled with friendly competition on your private, professionally lit tennis court, providing the perfect venue for both casual and competitive play. For those warm summer days, indulge in the refreshing waters of the inground pool, surrounded by lush custom-built landscaping that adds a touch of tranquility to the outdoor space. A pool storage house ensures that all your aquatic essentials are neatly organized, while a separate carriage/guest house offers a private retreat for visitors or additional accommodation options. Whether you're entertaining guests, hosting family gatherings, or simply seeking a retreat from the ordinary, this property offers an unparalleled lifestyle. The expansive 21 acres provide a sense of privacy and serenity, creating a haven for nature lovers and those seeking a respite from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. Don't miss the opportunity to make this extraordinary custom-built home your own! Experience the epitome of luxury living with a basement laid out for entertaining, fully lit tennis court, inground pool, and a charming carriage/guest house - all set against a backdrop of unparalleled natural beauty. Welcome home to your private paradise!

10648 S Auburn Hills Drive, Edinburgh

Listing courtesy of eXp Realty, LLC.

Start Your Search

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2024 Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of REALTORS®